Recent content by Account Deleted

  1. A

    Ruck clarification recieved today.

    1; My Communication clearly gives the office as the source. Therefore it is OFFICIAL not a "personal" comment. I highlighted that back in post 25. To claim I did not answer is untrue! Had the email been personal I'd have stated so the simple fact that It is from the office says it is not a...
  2. A

    Ruck clarification recieved today.

    1; My Communication clearly gives the office as the source. Therefore it is OFFICIAL not a "personal" comment. I highlighted that back in post 25. To claim I did not answer is untrue! Had the email been personal I'd have stated so the simple fact that It is from the office says it is not a...
  3. A

    Ruck clarification recieved today.

    Let's comp are the SA stance and the WRU stance Agreement! Agreement! Agreement! The video from Australia says the same thing! Hands on does not equal out! The ball must come CLEAR of the ruck to be out!
  4. A

    Ruck clarification recieved today.

    Let's comp are the SA stance and the WRU stance Agreement! Agreement! Agreement! The video from Australia says the same thing! Hands on does not equal out! The ball must come CLEAR of the ruck to be out!
  5. A

    Ruck clarification recieved today.

    I did reply. You've not bothered to read / have a problem reading the reply! As you have a problem reading the thread I'll repeat post 25 in full! So it is from the OFFICE not FRED the cleaner. I do hope that is clear to you! There is a clear reference to the request to the IRB REFEREE...
  6. A

    Ruck clarification recieved today.

    I did reply. You've not bothered to read / have a problem reading the reply! As you have a problem reading the thread I'll repeat post 25 in full! So it is from the OFFICE not FRED the cleaner. I do hope that is clear to you! There is a clear reference to the request to the IRB REFEREE...
  7. A

    Your reaction?

    Penalty and a word. Caveat: The player's tone may change that.
  8. A

    Your reaction?

    Penalty and a word. Caveat: The player's tone may change that.
  9. A

    Ruck clarification recieved today.

    Sorry but the bit I've highlighted is clearly a sarcastic questioning of the WRU and the integrity of the originator of the communication
  10. A

    Ruck clarification recieved today.

    Sorry but the bit I've highlighted is clearly a sarcastic questioning of the WRU and the integrity of the originator of the communication
  11. A

    Stopped short but not held

    Every offence (well almost) has an effect on a game: An offside player gets to the ball a fraction of a second earlier than he would have done had he stayed legal. Had he been legsl the catcher may have been able to pas the ball away. A pillar is in the eye line of an opponent and that second...
  12. A

    Stopped short but not held

    Every offence (well almost) has an effect on a game: An offside player gets to the ball a fraction of a second earlier than he would have done had he stayed legal. Had he been legsl the catcher may have been able to pas the ball away. A pillar is in the eye line of an opponent and that second...
  13. A

    ERC shock mutiny by elite clubs

    I think you miss the sarcasm. It is Our Irish / French friend (It seems that L'irlandais WAS flogging a dead horse [the ERC]) that seem not to see the truth. We have: The qualification rule changed. The seeding / ranking system changed. Funding changed. Clubs involved in the running of...
  14. A

    ERC shock mutiny by elite clubs

    I think you miss the sarcasm. It is Our Irish / French friend (It seems that L'irlandais WAS flogging a dead horse [the ERC]) that seem not to see the truth. We have: The qualification rule changed. The seeding / ranking system changed. Funding changed. Clubs involved in the running of...
  15. A

    Stopped short but not held

    I can see material effect being employed in the event of a crawler but with great care.